By
2005, house prices were rising
at the fastest pace since 1978,
the report states, and "media
reports of a housing bubble
reached a fever pitch. But, when
and if house prices do fall, the
so-called bubble is more likely
to deflate slowly rather than
burst suddenly."Typically,
job losses, overbuilding and
population outflows are factors
in home-price declines, the
report states. "While dips of a
few percentage points are
common, nominal house prices
rarely drop by 10 percent or
more." Though about half of the
nation's 75 largest metro areas
have seen nominal house prices
drop by 5 percent or more at
least once in the past 30 years.
Over the past several years,
real estate economists have said
that the strength in the housing
market has served to buoy the
nation's economy. Now, the
performance of the general
economy will help to determine
how well the housing market
weathers this slowdown.
"Housing's contribution to
economic growth is already
diminishing and will begin to
turn negative if home sales,
starts, and home equity
borrowing continue to decline."
Nicolas Retsinas, director of
the Joint Center for Housing
Studies, said, "We've turned the
corner, certainly, from a
seller's market to a buyer's
market. The days of double-digit
(price) appreciation are
certainly behind us. The
question before us, in this
period of price correction, is,
'Will it be a flattening for the
market or a more severe drop?'"
He added, "Overall, the
market is probably fairly solid,
but in the short term there will
be some rough patches. The wild
card ... is the economy."
While price appreciation is
slowing, Retsinas said that
prices likely will not moderate
enough to eliminate
affordability problems. Rising
energy costs have also affected
housing affordability. From
2001-04, the number of
households paying half of their
incomes for housing increased by
1.9 million -- an estimated 15.6
million low- and middle-income
households are classified as
having "severe cost burdens" for
housing, according to the
report. And about 49 percent of
poor working families with
children had severe cost burdens
in 2004, while 75 percent had at
least moderate burdens.
Affordable rental housing for
those earning $16,000 or less
each year shrank by about 13
percent from 1993 to 2003,
according to the report, and "a
significant portion of the
remaining affordable stock is in
financial stress."
Household growth is expected
to grow from about 12.6 million
over the past 10 years to 14.6
million in the next 10 years,
the report states, while
"widespread affordability
problems will also intensify."
An increase in foreclosures
is likely as the market
transitions, Retsinas said,
given that it may not be as easy
for some distressed homeowners
to sell their properties and
avoid a foreclosure process. "If
I had a problem making my
mortgage payment a year ago I
could put my house on the
market. If I had a problem this
year it might not be quite as
easy. I might not have that
'escape hatch.'"
Meanwhile, the overall
home-ownership rate dipped from
69 percent in 2004 to 68.9
percent in 2005, the first drop
after 12 consecutive years of
gain, according to the report,
as the rental market began to
rebound.
New single-family home sales
increased 6.7 percent from
2004-05, while existing
single-family home sales
increased 3.4 percent and
existing condo and co-op sales
grew 9.3 percent. Median new
single-family home prices grew
4.4 percent from 2004-05,
existing single-family prices
gained 9.4 percent, and existing
condo and co-op prices rose 13.4
percent.
"Although 2005 surpassed 2004
on many measures, housing
markets were clearly moderating.
Indeed, the year-over-year
change in sales of existing
homes turned negative late in
2005," the report states, noting
that a rise in interest rates is
the likely culprit.
Slowing sales boosted the
inventory of new and existing
homes to a supply of about 5.3
months to 5.5 months in March
2006. The months' supply is used
to gauge how long it would take
to exhaust the for-sale
inventory of homes given the
current sales rate. A supply of
six months is considered to be
roughly equilibrium between a
buyer's market and a seller's
market, with a shorter supply
indicating a seller's market and
a longer supply indicating a
buyer's market.
The inventory of condos
reached a "near-term
oversupply," the report also
concludes, with the supply
climbing from 3.9 months to 6.9
months.
Investor demand for real
estate is expected to cool,
according to the report. "In the
hottest markets, the overhang of
investor properties may be
absorbed rapidly if housing
production continues to fall.
The recent sharp increase in
vacant single-family homes for
rent suggests, however, that
this process will not be
smooth."
Investors bought 4 percent of
single-family homes built and 13
percent of condos sold,
according to a June 2005 survey
by the National Association of
Home Builders, while investors
bought an average 11 percent of
new single-family homes and 15
percent of condos in the 30
large markets that posted the
fastest price appreciation.
"Among the housing markets
with the highest investor loan
shares are several Florida and
inland California metros, as
well as Boise, Phoenix and Las
Vegas. In most markets, the
investor share more than doubled
from 2000 to 2005," the Harvard
report states.
"I think we've reached a
point where housing is no longer
seen as a purchase for
investment. It's something to
live in," Retsinas said.
The volume of sub-prime loans
has jumped "dramatically," the
report notes, from $210 billion
in 2001 to $625 billion in 2005,
with last year's sub-prime
lending total representing 20
percent of the dollar value of
loan originations and about 7
percent of mortgage debt
outstanding. The share of
sub-prime loans that were at
least 60 days delinquent or in
some stage of foreclosure was
seven times higher than that of
prime loans in fourth-quarter
2005.
Interest-only loans, which
defer principal payments for a
specified number of years, "went
from relative obscurity to an
estimated 20 percent of the
dollar value of all loans and 37
percent of adjustable-rate loans
originated in 2005," according
to the center's report.
"Payment-option loans, which let
borrowers make minimum payments
that are even lower than the
interest due on the loan and
roll the balance into the amount
owed, accounted for nearly 10
percent of last year's loan
originations."
Meanwhile, adjustable-rate
mortgages, which doubled their
share of the market to 35
percent in 2004, dropped
slightly to 31 percent in 2005.
The construction of new
rental properties has slowed
from 275,000 units in 2002 to
203,000 units in 2005, which –
along with the conversion of
some rental units to condo units
– has assisted in lowering the
vacancy rate from 10.2 percent
in 2004 to 9.6 percent at the
end of 2005.